So the second trailer for what may well be the biggest film of the year is now online. My initial reaction… a big, fat “Meh!”.
Look I want to like AVATAR I really do. I’m a massive James Cameron fan. Aliens is probably one of the best action films EVER made. TRUE LIES, ABYSS, TERMINATOR… all flawless movie experiences. But having now seen over 4 minutes of trailers for the film I honestly couldn’t be less excited. It’s all a bit… dull. Big machines & impressive vistas it may have but the story looks like Dances With Wolves 2 (Dances with Aliens) and I’m just not sure I care enough to sit through 2 hours plus of 3-D headache inducing computer imagery.
The problem however isn’t so much the visuals (although the CGI does make the film look like Ferngully) as much as the script. Okay now I’m saying this from JUST having seen the trailer but come on if the best line you can pick to sell your movie is “Your not in Kansas any more… your in Pandora” do little for Cameron’s reputation as a less than effective writer (11+ Oscar noms for Titanic, all major categories. ZERO for script).
In fact looking back at Titanic and the dialogue snippets I’ve heard so far from Avatar, Cameron is becoming scarily like George “Who needs actors or scripts” Lucas. Think about it – CGI actors, piss poor script… hmm.
Okay so I’m critiquing a film I haven’t yet seen but the trailer should excite me. It didn’t, it just left me cold. CGI has been around for years now. JURASSIC PARK wowed me as I’d never seen anything like it before. It blew me away. But that was 16 years ago. I’m no longer impressed by CGI. For my money it’s one thing to make a visually stunning film (again reserving judgement as for my money the film looks far from the photo-realistic epic we were promised), it’s another thing to make an engaging film that works on more than that one level.
To be honest it’s a hard task. that VERY few people get right. IRON MAN & STAR TREK were two recent films that managed to mix the big bangs with an engaging story & script. Get that right and you have a true blockbuster, get it wrong and you have the trade disputes boredom of STAR WARS: PHANTOM MENACE.
Despite all this I have no doubt that I’ll still be first in the queue to see AVATAR because I still hold a hope that Cameron, who is truly a master film maker, will once again recreate the magic of TRUE LIES or TERMINATOR 2. But I cant help feel that sinking feeling that we may have another STAR WARS: REVENGE OF THE SITH on our hands.
Guess well know in just a few short weeks.
AVATAR is out on 18th December 2009 worldwide. For more check out www2.avatarmovie.com.
Phil Hobden
Phil Hobden is an independent filmmaker and freelance writer. His second film, TEN DEAD MEN is out in the UK now and he is currently developing his third feature film through his company Modern Life?, as well as writing for various websites and magazines including Combat Magazine, Fighters, FarEastFilms.comand Impact. For more on Phil Hobden check out http://www.philhobden.co.uk/ or www.mod-life.net